While my kids and his kids were happily playing Minecraft via LAN in another room, Steve and I sat down at his dining room table and randomly drew teams for our first game. Our goal is to play through all the teams in Paydirt once, randomly selecting them for each game. I ended up with the Washington Redskins and Steve got the Phoenix Cardinals.
This version of the Paydirt team charts are based on the statistics of how well the teams did during the 1991 regular season, playoffs and Super Bowl. The Redskins had a regular season 14-2 win-loss record that year and went on to win the Super Bowl in early 1992 and their team chart certainly reflected that they were the best team of that season. Steve's Cardinals only had a 4-12 win-loss record in 1991 and his team chart certainly exhibited those statistics.
I won 72-7. Although there is player choice on which play to make (9 offensive plays consisting of 4 runs/5 passes, and 6 defensive formations) ultimately it comes down to dice roles and chart referencing. With evenly matched players, a very good team should invariably trounce a very bad team due to probability and their individual team chart. I guess in that way Paydirt could be called a good simulation.
Does that make for a fun game though? I suspect casual players and those not interested in American football would not enjoy Paydirt where there is a very real possibility of playing a game with such mismatched teams. Steve and I do enjoy watching NFL games (him being a San Francisco '49ers fan and me a Philadelphia Eagles fan) and so playing a simulation of a game, irregardless of how mismatched the teams were, was still fun. We must have a rematch of this game in the future though.
For our second game I randomly selected the LA Rams and Steve selected the San Diego Chargers. In this game our teams were fairly evenly matched with the team charts reflecting statistics in which the LA Rams had a 3-13 season and the San Diego Chargers had a 4-12 season (in other words - both equally crap teams).
This was a much closer and exciting game and was won by Steve's Chargers defeating my Rams 17-14 with a last minute field goal.